Once a day
Get Articles by e-mail:

Get Today's Climate by e-mail:

Climate Science Links

U.S. Government


Academic, Non-Governmental

Logging Loophole Under Attack at Cancun Climate Talks

The loophole would allow some 450 megatons of climate-changing emissions each year, or 5% of the global total, a new report says

By Stacy Feldman

Dec 1, 2010

CANCUN, MEXICO -- An arcane accounting rule governing emissions from logging forests that is now being negotiated at Cancun climate talks is threatening to put the integrity of a future global-warming deal at risk, environmental groups said in a new analysis.

The groups urged UN negotiators to shut the so-called loophole for good during the Nov 29-Dec. 10 talks.

The incentive would allow rich nations to ramp up logging without accounting for the greenhouse gases that result, in effect hiding emissions increases. It takes the form of a proposed revision of the (LULUCF) rules under the Kyoto Protocol.

"At the moment they're cheating so badly on the LULUCF that it's almost a joke," said Melanie Coath, senior climate change policy officer for the , one of the groups behind the research. "What we need are incentives for developed countries to reduce their current logging emissions, not increase them with impunity."

The new analysis is the first to quantify the loophole's impact on rich states, or Annex I nations. It claims the incentive would severely undermine countries' pledged emissions curbs, most notably Norway, Russia, Australia, Japan, Switzerland, the EU and New Zealand.

"The crazy one is New Zealand," Chris Henschel, policy manager at the , another group involved, told SolveClimate News.  

New Zealand aims to slash emissions across its economy by 10 to 20 percent by 2020. But the LULUCF loophole would allow the logging giant to cut down more trees and keep the emissions rise off the books.

The result would be a 45 percent increase in New Zealand's emissions, instead of a reduction, the analysis said.

Nearly every Annex I nation backs the loophole, though none would benefit as much as New Zealand.

Norway's plan to cut emissions between 30 and 40 percent, for instance, would end up being closer to 22 to 32 percent, according to the analysis. Russia's 15 to 25 percent target would turn into a 9.5 to 19.5 percent reduction, while Australia's 5 to 15 percent goal would shrink to 1 to 11 percent.

Creative Accounting

Known as the "reference level" approach, the loophole lets states increase forestry emissions for years, and then measure compliance against this elevated future amount.  

The approach is rare in UN climate negotiations. While different countries have pledged various baselines in the overall talks, they are all based on a past year, not a future level that each nation gets to pick for itself.

"Politically, there's a big attraction," Henschel said, especially for the EU, which often struggles to reach consensus on issues. The European bloc proposed the loophole last year.

"If everyone gets to pick what they want, it works for everyone," he added.

In total, the loophole would account for some 450 megatons of climate-changing emissions each year, according to the (CAN), a coalition of more than 500 organizations. That's equivalent to about 75 percent of Canada's total yearly emissions, or five percent of the global total.

Clearing forests is responsible for 20 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions, according to UN estimates. Managing the sector is seen as a critical component of a future global warming deal.

Africa Group, Tuvalu Protest

Negotiators are expected to finalize the rules on LULUCF in Cancun, where leaders hope to hammer out key elements of a new agreement to slow global warming.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <h1> <h2> <h3> <ul> <li> <ol> <b> <i> <p> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Youtube and google video links are automatically converted into embedded videos.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Images can be added to this post.

More information about formatting options